• 2021.02.01
    星期一

Road to 5**:30 million-dollar-subsidy to recycling firms

[2021.02.01] 發表
Mr. Ho(left), the owner of a 40-year-old recycling shop in Wan Chai, said that it is ''the worst in 40 years'' for the recycling industry. A scavenger on the right has brought cardboard boxes to the shop, praising the shop for always ''purchasing wastepaper for fair prices.''

【明報專訊】Cardboard boxes are a source of livelihood for many elderly scavengers, yet as the trade-in prices for recycled paper waste continue to fall, the volume of paper recycled is also decreasing. The Environmental Protection Department approved a subsidy of $30 million from the Recycling Fund to subsidize frontline recyclers according to the amount of recycled paper waste they receive, hoping to encourage frontline waste pickers to continue collecting cardboard boxes.

◆News summary

Applications began to be accepted on September 13, 2019. A monitoring committee was set up to ensure the smooth operation of the project as well as the appropriate use of funds. According to Lau Yau Sing, President of the Hong Kong Environmental Protection and Recycle Industry Sustainable Development Association, participating recyclers must purchase wastepaper at no less than $0.5 per kilogram, which is higher than current market price of $0.3 by over 60 percent.

Lau points out that in 2019, paper-making factories on the mainland offered to acquire wastepaper for $800 per tonne, a sharp fall from over $1,000 in 2018. As a result of the ripple effect, wastepaper exporters purchase wastepaper from recycling firms for $500, and recycling firms purchase wastepaper from waste pickers for $0.3 per kilogram. The prices have reached their lowest point, and ''no one will collect these (cardboard boxes) anymore if prices drop further.''

Source: Ming Pao, 30 September 2019

■Mock examination question

Are government subsidies the most effective method to raise wastepaper recycling rates in Hong Kong? Support your argument with evidence.

◆Agree

•Provide enough incentives

Through cash subsidies, the government can provide sufficient financial incentives to raise wastepaper recycling rates. According to the information provided, if scavengers have no desire to collect cardboard boxes, the amount of wastepaper purchased by recycling firms decreases, so do recycling rates. Subsidies will be more efficient than public education, as the latter requires a prolonged period of time to take effect and does not provide immediate incentives.

•Public support

The public or recycling firms directly benefit from cash subsidies, and this will result in higher level of public support and thus higher feasibility. This will help increase the recycling rate of wastepaper. While the establishment of more recycling facilities is considered inconvenient by some citizens, cash subsidies can provide direct intervention and assistance in the recycling industry as well as the lives of citizens, which should be more effective.

◆Disagree

•A cosmetic exercise only

Cash subsidies provide only incentives but do not get to the root of the problem, so it is not the most effective solution. On the contrary, changing the recycling industry by reducing reliance on the mainland market, which will make wastepaper recycling prices less affected by external market factors, is a more effective solution.

•Unable to raise recycling rates in the long run

Governmental funding also has its limits, and it is considered a short-term measure. Although cash subsidies can directly encourage the public to recycle, they also increase government expenditures. On the contrary, increasing recycling facilities in urban areas is more beneficial to citizens. Altering the habits of the public in the long run should be more helpful in increasing willingness to recycle wastepaper.

Translated by Odyssey Lang

[通通識 第692期]

更多教育
每周焦點.調查:逾半智障生  曾遭排斥
【明報專訊】■1月17日(個人成長與人際關係、今日香港) 社會服務機構「親切」2021年1月17日公布「香港智障人士參與社區體育運動研... 詳情
怎樣穿衣最保暖?
【明報專訊】根據天文台於2020/21年冬季季度預報,受拉尼娜現象(沿海海水異常變冷)及較強東北季候風影響,今年冬天氣溫偏低。 天氣寒... 詳情
STEAM足[:洋b穿衣法最保暖
【明報專訊】Joanne說:「學懂如何穿衣最保暖前,首先要了解保暖的原理。」我們可根據熱力傳遞的原理,以及衣服的物料成分,了解如何穿衣最保暖... 詳情
時事常識挑戰(香港):疫下過新年
【明報專訊】快到農曆新年了,為防止疫情惡化,需避免人群聚集,降低病毒傳播風險,今年農曆新年變得不一樣,部分過往必做的賀年活動都要取消或縮小規... 詳情
【明報專訊】(1)B (2)D (3)A (4)C (5)C (6)D (7)A (8)B ... 詳情

明報網站 · 版權所有 · 不得轉載
Copyright © 2021 mingpaocanada.com All rights reserved.
Ming Pao Daily News A wholly owned subsidiary of Ming Pao Enterprise Corporation Ltd.
Vancouver Chinese Newspaper

5368 Parkwood Place, Richmond B.C. V6V 2N1 | Tel.: (604) 231-8998 | Fax: (604) 231-9881/9884 | Advertising Hotline Tel.: (604) 231-8992